Review: The Savage Arctic

Today we’re looking at The Savage Arctic, published by Jeff Stevens games and written by no fewer than 7 people. It’s a “zine” in the mold of the Cursed Scrolls – some classes, some spells, a hexcrawl and some adventures.

The map has 190 hexes of which 22 are keyed. For my taste, a lot of the hexes stop just short of being really gameable. For example, “Hidden within the mountains, two clans of goat giants feud over boundary lines and hunting grounds. Secretly, Pluego, the son of the Hoof Clan’s ruling matriarch, and Flinga, the daughter of the Horn Clan’s lead hunter meet regularly in a secluded cave, one day hoping to wed and unite their clans.” Neat, but how does that hook the players? What adventuring can be had here? There’s a tunnel that holds the corpse of a purple worm that feeds “exotic creatures” (which ones?) and invites you to ponder where the tunnel leads (yeah, where?). Connecting those dots is the most difficult part for me as a GM, and that’s the kind of help I’m looking for when I buy a book. Perhaps some folks expect to do this work themselves but there are plenty of examples of how it can be done effectively and with minimal text.

The random encounters are pretty well done. They come in two forms – there’s a main “Traveling Encounters” table, and then some of the adventures have a list of random encounters that tie back to that adventure, offering a nice hook. It would have been nice to have integrated those encounters into a unified table. But at least they offer some interesting and dynamic situations to interact with. “Five shivering peasants walking aimlessly. They were on a sightseeing expedition led by their arctic guide Biltho Voth (thief). A favorite scheme of his, Biltho left them to freeze after stealing their valuables.” Good stuff. However, the table is 2d8, which will create a bell curve of results where I think it was probably not intended.

I’m going to review each of the individual adventures and provide a single score at the end.

The Snowshoe Raiders

This one is the hideout of some snow troll raiders “that have largely evaded detection by wearing snowshoes to conceal their tracks.” I’m not really sure how this is intended to work because that’s not at all what snow shoes do. I’m also not sure how this is supposed to work: “Within far, 1:6 chance per hour that the ice breaks; victim is completely submerged…” I think what it’s trying to say is that for every far distance traveled, there’s a 1:6 chance…” But even then, remember that “far” means “within sight” and inside a dungeon with small rooms that means almost nothing at all, and could in fact be less than “near”. So this was perhaps not the appropriate measurement to help GMs adjudicate this particular effect. Also no word on why the trolls, described in the core book as “giants”, do not suffer this hazard.

The dungeon itself has 8 rooms. It’s a bit mundane, without any mysteries, puzzles or anything at all going on beneath the surface. There’s a few trolls, their prisoner, their leader, and their half-orc peddler ally. Whatever interesting content the GM is able to conjure from this scenario will have to derive from the NPCs, but we don’t have much to go on. The leader has an “elder mind” ability that allows it to speak with its dead ancestors. We’re told it’s using this ability but not why or how it will impact the PCs. The peddler will simply alert the frost trolls of the party’s presence and the prisoner isn’t given any goals or secrets. Everything is, more or less, exactly as it appears. Neither is there enough here to offer an interesting raid or infiltration adventure.

The Ice Jackals
The setup here is that some bandits are using an ice-bound frigate as a base of operations to raid the nearby communities, and that they believe one day it will thaw and they can escape to sunnier climes with their ill-gotten gains. However, their leader is keeping secret that the frigate has a ruptured hull and will never sail again. She’s afraid that if her crew finds that out, they’ll mutiny.

This is a potentially interesting little situation for the players to interact with. If they can somehow learn that secret and inform the crew, they could solve the raiding problem without having to fight a dozen bad guys and maybe take over as leader or whatever. But instead, the only really conceivable way for them to find the rupture is to make their way past all the bandits and their leader as they descend to the bottom of the ship. So there’s a good chance everyone will be dead before the PCs become aware that the rupture matters at all.

So this barely qualifies as an adventure. It’s a 6-room ship with minimal interactivity besides making a check to pass the various DCs needed to open doors and locks. The NPCs are given flavorful names like “Seamus ‘Pappy’ Greenbottom” and “Marta ‘Snake Eye’ Novak” but they aren’t given any actual flavor in the form of interesting and learnable desires, secrets, or anything of that nature. It’s another case where the creator has done the easy part of creating a map with some basic room keys, but hasn’t given us any interesting ways to interact with it.

Lich King of the Glacial Palace

A level 7+ adventure featuring a lich, and a dragon. And a palace. In 6 pages of text. The setup is that an ancient and powerful lich lives inside a magical ice palace and wants to eat the sun. There’s just not enough here to do the premise of the adventure justice. It needs scope and danger befitting the subject matter and high level of the party, but we start with a maze (MAZES NEVER WORK IN D&D) and then a dragon that you can cut a deal with (and you might as well because it has no treasure) and then you meet a dwarf that will give you a pearl to get you past the sahuagin guards that defend the entrance to the lich’s lair.

Once there you will get into a pitched battle with a lich. There are some environmental hazards to reckon with and it will be a tough fight but you can’t beat the action economy and this poor fella is all alone in there. Except for his phylactery, which is conveniently located in the base of his throne. Look, the point of a phylactery is to be the ultimate final puzzle that allows you to defeat an otherwise impossible foe. Keeping it at arm’s length defeats the entire purpose.

So you kill the lich, bust up his furniture, and what do you get? “Roll twice per party member on the ‘Treasure 10+’ table and four times per party member on the ‘Treasure 7–9’ table.” I suppose generic, random fitting is appropriate here, and matches the effort put into the rest of the adventure. But what designer wouldn’t relish the opportunity to come up with some cool, custom magic items?

The Owl Clan

This one is a few points of interest and a 7-room dungeon. It’s presented as a sort of open-ended situation: the Owl Clan pissed off some evil spirits and now they’re in the middle of a severe famine. The root cause is that a dude was turned into a terrible monster. Now, we’re told that the Owl Clan has a deal with the evil spirits to occasionally turn people into monsters but I guess this was the wrong dude?

So you chat with the locals, get some background info, and then head into the dungeon.It builds up to a choice where the party can either kill the monster, or work with him and kill the shaman that betrayed him. All in all, not a bad little scenario. The dungeon is short but has some wonderfully creepy imagery and vibes. I would have liked a few words on what happens depending on the party’s choices.

Gold Finger Mining Company

This isn’t so much an adventure as it is the description of a somewhat mundane mining operation. There’s a crap ton of gold, though, so I’m sure more than a few parties will choose the “rob them blind” route, which wouldn’t be too difficult. Especially if they have no qualms about killing the peasant-statted workers.

We do get some adventure ideas. Most of them are “there’s monsters in the mine”. Not exactly groundbreaking stuff. At least none of them sound as fun as simply finding a way to steal all the gold. I should mention that most of the gold is in a safe, and the text doesn’t even give us a DC for opening it, let alone a cleverly hidden or encoded combination. Boo.

Heavy Pan Mining Company

Another one? It’s the same as above but worse because it doesn’t actually have any treasure.

Face in the Cliffs

In this one, a gnome lives inside the nostril of the titular face in the cliff. She has drunk from the cursed water inside and has an insatiable thirst for knowledge. The dungeon has 9 areas. Most of them contain mundane stuff. No real loot except the gnome’s books. We’re told they’re worth 1,000 gp but not how many there are or how many gear slots they take.

One room, the latrine, has a secret passage to the gnome’s bedroom. I can’t imagine what the point of this is, because there is another, very obvious entrance to the same room. There’s also a secret door to the final room that contains the pool of cursed water. The gnome turns into a night hag if you try to drink it. Here’s the curse: “You crave knowledge and how to apply it. Daily, you must spend 4 hours reading or crafting. Otherwise, take 1d6 damage. You also crave the pool’s water and fear losing it to others. Can only be removed by a wish spell, or by touching the horn of a unicorn.” Does that sound like the type of grenade you want to toss into the middle of your campaign? One where the afflicted PCs just want to sit in the cave and read? Maybe if your players have a stable of PCs to choose from, but otherwise, probably not.

But still, there’s an interesting setup and encounter with the gnome here. And if the PCs decide to try and help her that might spur some fun adventures.

Sarilux’s Den

The final dungeon is a fire dragon’s lair. It starts with a perilous mountain climb, including a table of hazards that is rolled every hour. At least we are given the travel time, which is more than I can say for many such scenarios. There is also a random table for what the eponymous dragon is doing when the party shows up. One possibility is that the dragon has died of old age, and a lamp in its hoard has released an efreeti. Certainly an interesting twist but maybe a disappointment if the party was looking forward to slaying Sarilux.

The lair has 8 areas. Some of them have some good interactivity. There’s a pile of dragon poop with a magic mace but you might catch a disease from pulling it out. You can also spend 10 minutes searching the pile to find more loot, but if you aren’t already screaming “THERE ARE NO MINUTES IN SHADOWDARK” then you must be new around here. Rounds. We measure crawling in rounds.

Besides the poop there’s a lot of lava hazards. The treasure room contains “500 gp worth of coin and gemstones”. Enough treasure to nearly fill a mason jar. That’s the age old problem with dragon hoards in D&D. The amount of treasure depicted on the old red box set would be like zillions of GP, and that’s not really practical in game terms. BUT Shadowdark has a few built-in fail safes: 1) RAW, a dragon’s hoard is 10 xp no matter how big. 2) there isn’t a lot to spend money on besides carousing (usually limited to once per downtime between adventures) and 3) PCs are severely limited in what they can carry. So I don’t think it would hurt too much to tack a zero onto that treasure amount.

The dragon’s room is filled with more lava hazards and he has a lair action that can cause the walls and ceiling to collapse. It’s not bad for a dragon’s lair, even if it is exactly what you would expect. But this is worth pulling out and dropping in the mountains of your campaign’s map.

The end

There’s nothing in this book that I feel excited to run. It’s mostly serviceable – the layout is easy to follow and most of the adventures have a modicum of interactivity. But I’m not sensing a lot of passion on the part of the designers. Maybe that’s a symptom of this being someone else’s project for most of them. But it all seems a bit rote, like if your English teacher assigned homework to write a dungeon. You do just well enough to pass the class.

On a scale of 2-12, The Savage Arctic gets 5 stingbats.

https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/579545/the-savage-arctic-shadowdark-rpg

Responses

  1. John Watson Avatar

    Could the “it takes 10 minutes” be a signal that you should use “time passes” for searching the pile? That’s what I’ve generally done when an adventure uses minutes like that, and it seems to work out ok.

    1. Jordan Rudd Avatar

      Maybe, but since random encounters, spell effects, etc are usually tied to rounds, it’s more helpful to give rounds than minutes. “10 minutes” doesn’t tell me how many random encounters to roll.

      1. John Watson Avatar

        Rules as written, you roll one random encounter check at 50% chance after “minutes pass”

      2. Jordan Rudd Avatar

        Well I stand corrected. But I still prefer rounds, especially for a discrete action like “search the poop”. Especially in this case where it specifies that a single person is searching for 10 minutes, so it creates a sort of asynchronicity with other PCs who might be doing things that are measured in rounds.

Leave a Reply